Bennewitz photographed saucer craft on the ground near the Archuleta Mesa from his plane. AFOSI agents and the Moore-Shandera group subsequently confiscated every print.
In January 1998, Brad Smith posted a short message to an online forum that quietly detonated several foundational assumptions of the Dulce narrative. Smith had spoken directly with Paul Bennewitz in extended phone conversations in 1988–89, calling him at Thunder Scientific. Bennewitz was “spacey but understandable.” He was a pilot who flew regularly between Albuquerque and Denver, and on several flights over the Archuleta Mesa he had photographed saucer craft on the ground, black cars nearby, and humans. Most of those photographs were stolen from his house by AFOSI agents — Richard Doty and others — accompanied by Bill Moore. The last of his photographic proof vanished after a visit from Shandera, Moore, and Tracy Tormé.
Smith’s most provocative claim reframes the entire Dulce narrative: the facility beneath Archuleta Mesa is not an alien base — it is a top-secret bio-genetic laboratory conducting human cloning. The vats of body parts described by abductee Christa Tilton are not alien food supplies but cloned limbs in growth medium. The “big brown alien eyes” are the product of inserting cow eye DNA into doctored human eggs. The cattle mutilations were performed by black helicopter crews, not aliens. And Christa Tilton, Smith claims, was not abducted by ETs but was a mind-controlled Air Force dependent used since age 16 as a guinea pig for egg harvesting. In two paragraphs, Smith replaces the alien hypothesis with a purely terrestrial — and arguably more horrifying — explanation.
Brad Smith on Paul Bennewitz and Dulce
From: Brad Smith <chair@thule.org>Date: Mon, 26 Jan 1998 19:47:51 -0800
I spoke to Paul twice in extended conversations in 1988-89. I called Thunder Scientific. He was spacey but understandable. He was a pilot. His business took him from Albuquerque to Denver frequently. He told me he had taken some photos out of the plane on several different trips on his way over the Archuleta Mesa.
These pictures showed saucer craft on the ground, black cars nearby, and humans. Most of the pictures were stolen from his house by the AFOSI (Doty and others including Moore), but he still had a couple left. Then Shandera, Moore and Tracy Torme (Mel’s son) made a tour of the Mesa, then down to Albuquerque to “visit” with Paul. When they left he was missing the last of his photographic “proof”.
My contention is that Paul’s problems didn’t start because of Manzano but because of these aerial pictures of wingless craft near Dulce. Christa Tilton was “abducted” and taken to an “underground” “alien base”. Turns out after my conversation with Christa in 1992 that she is kind of waking out of her mind controlled fog and realizing that she had been mind controlled from an early age (16) and made to do favors for AF personnel.
She was an AF brat. Later, she was used as a first abductee guinea pig for her eggs. Turns out the facility underneath Archuleta Mesa is a top secret bio-genetic lab. They are doing human cloning there and have made all sorts of heinous monsters
They do have vats of human body parts floating in liquid there (as per Christa) but far from aliens using them for “food”, they are cloned limbs in growth medium being readied for experimental implantation. There is technology on Earth that is always 50 years ahead of what humans are made aware of.
They broke the DNA code in 1979. Able to “insert” cow eye DNA into doctored human egg, bingo BIG BROWN ALIEN EYES!!! Linda Howe is an exaggerator par excellence. Those “cattle mutilations” were all done by black helicopter crews.
The cover up goes deep, but it is less consistent now because they are out of money like everybody.</chair@thule.org>
Executive Summary:
The Terrestrial Reframe — Brad Smith’s Conversations with Bennewitz and the Claim That Dulce Is a Human Cloning Lab
Brad Smith’s January 1998 online post documents two extended phone conversations with Paul Bennewitz in 1988–89, during which Bennewitz described aerial photographs of saucer craft on the ground near the Archuleta Mesa — photographs subsequently stolen by AFOSI agents (Richard Doty and others) and by the Shandera-Moore-Tormé group. Smith’s post reframes the Dulce narrative entirely: the facility is a top-secret bio-genetic laboratory conducting human cloning, not an alien base. The “alien” features (large brown eyes) are the product of cross-species DNA insertion, the body-part vats contain cloned limbs in growth medium, and the cattle mutilations were conducted by black helicopter crews.
Smith also claims that abductee Christa Tilton was not taken by aliens but was a mind-controlled Air Force dependent used for egg harvesting since age 16 — a claim Tilton herself was reportedly beginning to corroborate by 1992 as she “woke out of her mind controlled fog.”
As Smith frames the technological gap:
“There is technology on Earth that is always 50 years ahead of what humans are made aware of. They broke the DNA code in 1979.”
About the Author
